10 Reasons Workers’ Comp Claims Are Denied in New York
10 Reasons Workers’ Comp Claims Are Denied in New York
Attorney Reviewed | 5 Min Read
Content reviewed by the attorneys at Aronova & Associates · Last updated October 30, 2026 · Editorial Policy
A denial letter can feel like the end of the road, but it is not. In New York, most Workers’ Compensation denials come down to missed deadlines, disputed medical evidence or an argument that the injury did not happen at work. Workers’ Compensation is a no-fault system, which means you can receive benefits even if the accident was your own fault. A denial can be challenged before a Workers’ Compensation judge, and a judge’s decision can be appealed within 30 days.
At Aronova & Associates, our New York Workers’ Compensation lawyers challenge denied claims and represent injured workers at every hearing. Every case begins with a free consultation.
Key Facts: The Rules Behind Most Denials
| Rule | What New York law says |
|---|---|
| Notice to your employer | In writing, within 30 days of the injury |
| Filing your claim | Within 2 years of the accident; for an occupational illness, within 2 years of when you became disabled and knew, or should have known, it was work-related |
| Fault | No-fault system: who caused the accident generally does not matter |
| Narrow exceptions | An injury caused solely by intoxication, or by a deliberate intent to injure yourself or someone else |
| Challenging a judge’s decision | Ask the Board for review within 30 days |
| Cost of a lawyer | No upfront fee; the fee is set by law and approved by a Workers’ Compensation judge |
1. Late Notice to Your Employer
New York law requires written notice to your employer within 30 days of a work injury. A judge may excuse late notice in some circumstances, but late notice gives the insurance company an early basis to dispute the claim.
2. The Claim Was Not Filed Within Two Years
A claim must be filed with the Workers’ Compensation Board within two years of the accident. For an occupational illness, the deadline is two years from when you became disabled and knew, or should have known, that the illness was caused by your work. Claims filed after the deadline are generally barred.
3. The Insurance Company Disputes That the Injury Is Work-Related
The insurance company may argue that the injury happened at home, during your commute or otherwise outside the scope of your job. Injuries during an ordinary commute are generally not covered, so the details of where and how the injury occurred are critical.
4. The Insurance Company Blames a Pre-Existing Condition
Insurance companies frequently argue that a condition existed before the work injury. Under New York law, however, a work injury that aggravates or worsens a pre-existing condition can still be covered.
5. The Insurance Company’s Doctor Disagrees With Yours
The insurance company can require you to see a doctor of its choosing for an Independent Medical Examination (IME). If that doctor reports that you are not disabled, or that the injury is unrelated to work, the insurance company may use the report to deny or reduce your benefits.
Was Your Claim Denied? We Are Here to Help.
Our New York Workers’ Compensation lawyers can review the denial and explain your options. Call (516) 640-3900 for a free consultation.
6. Insufficient Medical Documentation
Gaps in treatment, or medical reports that do not explain how the injury happened and every body part affected, weaken a claim. Consistent treatment and complete records are among the strongest evidence you can have.
7. Treatment From a Provider Not Authorized by the Board
Except in emergencies, treatment generally must come from a provider authorized by the Workers’ Compensation Board, or the bills may not be paid. A new state law will remove this requirement beginning January 1, 2028.
8. You Were Classified as an Independent Contractor
If your employer treats you as an independent contractor rather than an employee, the insurance company may argue that you are not covered at all. A worker’s classification depends on the actual working relationship, not the label, and it can be challenged.
9. Intoxication or Intentional Injury
Benefits can be denied if the injury was caused solely by intoxication, or by a deliberate intent to injure yourself or someone else. These are narrow exceptions to the no-fault rule.
10. Missed Hearings or Deadlines
Failing to appear at a scheduled hearing, or to respond to notices from the Board, can delay a claim or result in it being closed.
How Our Lawyers Challenge a Denied Claim
- Answering the insurance company’s case: A denial means the insurance company already has a reason on file and a lawyer or representative to defend it. We build the case that answers it.
- Building the evidence: A judge decides disputed claims based on medical reports, testimony and, often, a report from the insurance company’s own doctor. We know what the judge needs to see, and we make sure it is in the record.
- Tracking every deadline: If a judge rules against you, an appeal must be filed within 30 days of the decision. We make sure no deadline is missed.
Why Injured Workers Choose Aronova & Associates
Many injured workers come to us after a denial, when the process starts to feel like forms and phone calls instead of real help. We review the denial, explain what the insurance company is arguing and tell you plainly what it will take to challenge it.
- A dedicated Workers’ Compensation team: Our lawyers represent injured New Yorkers before the Workers’ Compensation Board every day.
- Help in your language: Our team speaks 8+ languages, so you can discuss your claim in the language you are most comfortable with.
- Every benefit, coordinated: We also handle Social Security Disability, disability pension and personal injury cases, so one claim does not undercut another.
No Upfront Cost to Start Your Case
You pay nothing upfront. Your lawyer’s fee is set by New York law, approved by a Workers’ Compensation judge and paid from the benefits awarded.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I appeal a denied Workers’ Comp claim in New York?
Yes. A disputed claim is decided by a Workers’ Compensation judge, and the judge’s decision can be appealed to the Board within 30 days.
Can I be denied because the accident was my fault?
Generally, no. Because Workers’ Compensation is a no-fault system, benefits do not depend on who caused the accident. The main exceptions are injuries caused solely by intoxication or by an intent to cause injury.
What if nobody saw my accident?
Witnesses are helpful but not required. Prompt notice to your employer, consistent medical records and consistent statements can establish a claim.
Do I need a lawyer if my claim was denied?
You are not required to have one, but the insurance company will be represented, and the evidence presented at the hearing stage is generally what any appeal is decided on. A lawyer builds that record from the start, at no upfront cost.
Sources
Talk With a New York Workers’ Compensation Lawyer About Your Denied Claim
If your claim has been denied, you have the right to challenge it, and the evidence presented at the hearing stage often decides the outcome. Our Long Island and New York City Workers’ Compensation lawyers can build that record and fight for the benefits you are owed.
Call (516) 640-3900 or contact our team for a free consultation.
Attorney Advertising. This article provides general information about New York law and is not legal advice about your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Subscribe for our monthly Newsletter! Receive insights, views from the experts right in your inbox.
Contact Us
Ready to Work For You
Aronova & Associates is a firm for all New Yorkers. We are your trusted legal support when it matters most. Our team provides multilingual, tailored guidance to meet the diverse needs of New Yorkers. The first step in providing you with the help you need is a free consultation to discuss your case. When you’re ready to talk, we’re ready to work for you.
- 24 / 7
We Offer Legal Representation In:
- Spanish
- Russian
- Korean
- Hindi
- Gujarati
- Punjabi
- Urdu
- Turkish